Three and a half stars out of four. As a Star Wars fan, you can expect me to be a bit biased, but I will try to be fair. The action in this movie was excellent, hitting hard from the very beginning. The dialogue, particularly Anakin's and Padme's, is a bit...awkward, unnatural. They have no chemistry for one, and it's apparent that romance movies aren't George Lucas's forte. That minor detail is definitely forgiveable, though, because this movie isn't about romance. This movie is about the temptation, struggle, and fall of Anakin Skywalker. And he does it extremely well. Too well, in fact, as I heard that Lucas had to edit out certain scenes because Hayden Christiansen, the actor that plays Skywalker, looked
too evil. I'm thinking, there's no such thing, and that's the point anyways, isn't it? Ewan McGregor has always done a very respectable job as Obi-wan Kenobi in the previous two films, but this time, he's more than respectable, he's great. Just as Anakin is almost delightfully evil, Obi-wan is extremely, well...good, what else can I say? And he disturbingly resembles Sir Alec Guinness from the original trilogy...and they didn't even have to use any make-up, can you believe it? As for the rest of the cast, Ian McDiarmid, the actor who played Emperor Palpatine, has always been, and always will be, one of my favorite movie villains, and he does an Oscar-deserving job of it. Samuel L. Jackson's character, Mace Windu, comes to an end, but is awesomely cool before he dies. Natalie Portman...we can just ignore her, she was the only mediocre part of this film. And Yoda, my favorite...he fights the most awesome fight in all of the Star Wars films....well, he tied with Anakin's and Obi-wan's fight, that was going on at the same time...but it was still totally cool, and you gain a new respect for just how powerful that little green dude is.
And I don't even need to say anything about special effects, as ILM has delivered enough to let the movie speak for itself. It's enough to give WETA Workshop a run for its money.
The music....it's John Williams, need I say more? He's one of the greatest composers in history, ranking right up there with all of the old classical guys, and Gershwin, Mancini, Weber, and Wagner.
In closing, this movie was definitely worthy of the legacy that the original trilogy began. George Lucas found the magic again, and he really lets us have it.
Star Wars, Episode III: Revenge of the Sith